WPC/ Ip~?Wt⡜Iiܙ~6O*SP?QNT1Z1G6<:jE?rK 5$lc&2;#iO!C_ Ev.z##+;@Qr frun::Go!ڭVgUrEN?ǭ\(R}ܨܽd/2^(!rY@7UwdB0emNY12ɐBm{=s]ڳRtYPymltvTE9҄#8">$EژEAYQ8#xd緅&FIDjbjz@"O$a\(NbJL-0aӎpAg&:넾cGg_[u\1}q 7*V`7 χᴓ ՇCwuB66_$PQ 9 %eLI}؇s#!JUNk % 0( N ^ w@ 45 I X mZ UNq D 0l 0DoNNU> BHP LaserJet 4,,,,0(hH  Z6Times New Roman RegularX($44 -.I/0D1D23H4D56Eiu3@0 3|x6 Ux9 Z6Times New Roman Regular :_ @  @ XX   ` 1. Rule3700(D)(1)oftheRulesofProfessionalConductofthe  StateBarofCaliforniaprovides:8 `  Amemberwhoseemploymenthasterminatedshall:#` x` x 7 #8 `  (1)Subjecttoanyprotectiveorderornondisclosureagreement,promptlyreleasetotheclient,attherequestoftheclient,alltheclientpapersandproperty.Clientpapersandpropertyincludescorrespondence,pleadings,depositiontranscripts,exhibits,physicalevidence,expertsreports,andotheritemsreasonablynecessarytotheclientsrepresentation,whethertheclienthaspaidforthemornot;...((3$ !      0  (#$  0   %\  `&Times New Roman    d !  _XX8 Xdd8SIXTHDISTRICTAPPELLATEPROGRAM  DALLASSACHERAssistantDirectorStateBar#100175100N.WinchesterBlvd.,Suite310SantaClara,CA95050(408)2416171Attorneysfor#X XG#ԀXX Appellant,   JohnScopes :@<<INTHECOURTOFAPPEALOFTHESTATEOFCALIFORNIA@!!SIXTHAPPELLATEDISTRICTPEOPLEOFTHESTATEOFCALIFORNIA,0 p ]p p   `     h      p ]NO.H020666 `  PlaintiffandRespondent,0  0p  ]p p   `     h      p ](SANTACLARACO. ` vs.0 0 0h  0h h 0  0p  ]SUPERIORCOURTp p   `     h      p ]NO.GG123456)# :#JOHNSCOPES :,   h      p ]   `     h      p ] `  DefendantandAppellant.0  0p  ]p p  0 ` 0 ` ` 0 0h  0h h 0  0p  ] XX :p p  __________________________________________]#X XX X2#XX @} } MOTIONFORANORDERDIRECTING   @ ATTORNEYCLARENCE_DARROW_ԀTOPROVIDE@ DOCUMENTSFROMAPPELLANTSTRIALFILE@{ { 򀀀 #    ` TOTHEHONORABLECONRADL.RUSHING,PRESIDINGJUSTICEOFTHECOURTOFAPPEAL,SIXTHAPPELLATEDISTRICT: ` Appellantmovesthiscourtforanorderdirectinghistrialattorney,Clarence_Darrow_,toprovidedocumentsfromappellantstrialfiletohis *%& presentappellatecounsel,DallasSacher.ThedocumentsinquestionarethosespecifiedinMr.SacherslettertoMr._Darrow_ԀofMarch1,2006.Thismotionissupportedbytheattachedmemorandumofpointsandauthoritiesanddeclaration.Dated:May___,2006 `     h   Respectfullysubmitted, `     h   DALLASSACHER `     h   AttorneyforAppellant, `     h   JohnScopes     @@{ { MEMORANDUMOFPOINTSANDAUTHORITIES   @"PROCEDURALFACTS ` Appellatecounselhasreadtherecordonappealandcommunicated  withappellant.(ExhibitA.)Appellatecounselhasmadeadeterminationthatheisrequiredtoinvestigatepossibleissuesofineffectiveassistanceoftrialcounsel.(ExhibitA.)OnMarch1,2006,appellatecounselwrotetotrialcounsel,Clarence_Darrow_,andaskedhimtoforwardcopiesofspecifieddiscoveryprovidedbytheDistrictAttorneyortoindicatethatnosuchdiscoveryhadbeenprovided.(ExhibitA.)Havingreceivednoresponsetohisletter,appellatecounselsentfollowuplettersonMarch10,2006andMarch27,2006.(ExhibitA.)Todate,appellatecounselhasheardnothingfromMr._Darrow_.(ExhibitA.)  I.8 ` THISCOURTSHOULDORDERMR._DARROW_ԀTOCOMPLYWITHHISMANDATORYDUTYTOPROVIDETHEREQUESTEDDOCUMENTSFROMAPPELLANTSTRIALFILE. ` x` x  ` Pursuanttorule3700(D)(1)oftheRulesofProfessionalConductoftheStateBarofCalifornia,   #  1      trialcounselhasamandatorydutytoprovide %!! papersfromtheclientsfiletosuccessorcounsel.(_Kallen_Ԁv._Delug_(1984)  157Cal.App.3d940,950;Weissv.Marcus(1975)51Cal.App.3d590,599.)  Inthiscase,appellatecounselhasaskedMr._Darrow_Ԁtoprovidecopiesofspecifieddocuments.ItisMr._Darrow_Ԁdutytoprovidethesedocumentstoappellatecounselortoindicatethathedoesnothavethem.(Ibid.)    ` AcademyofCaliforniaOptometrists,Inc.v.SuperiorCourt(1975)51   Cal.App.3d999governsthiscase.There,theplaintiffinacivilactiondischargedhislawyer.Whenthedischargedlawyerdeclinedtoturntheclientsfileovertosuccessorcounsel,theCourtofAppealorderedhimtodoso.(Id.,atp.1006.)Whilethecourtdidnotciteanyauthorityinsupportof  itsorder,itismanifestthatamplestatutoryauthorityexists. ` CodeofCivilProceduresection187provides:8 `  Whenjurisdictionis,bytheConstitutionorthisCode,orbyanyotherstatute,conferredonaCourtorjudicialofficer,allthemeansnecessarytocarryitintoeffectarealsogiven;andintheexerciseofthisjurisdiction,ifthecourseofproceedingbenotspecificallypointedoutbythisCodeorthestatute,anysuitableprocessormodeofproceedingmaybeadoptedwhichmayappearmostconformabletothespiritofthiscode."` x` x ЇSection187appliestoproceedingspendingonappeal.(Warrenv._Schecter_  (1997)57Cal.App.4th1189,1199.)Asthiscourthasrecognized,section187authorizesacourttoprovideaproceduralremedytoalitigantwhosesubstantiverightsareestablishedunderthelaw.(_Topa_ԀIns.Co.v.Firemans   FundIns.Companies(1995)39Cal.App.4th1331,13441345.)    ` Here,thereisnodoubtthatMr._Darrow_Ԁhasalegaldutytoprovidethedocumentsrequestedbyappellatecounsel.Thus,thiscourtshouldorderMr._Darrow_Ԁtodoso.(Section187.) ` Asidefromsection187,CodeofCivilProceduresection128,subdivision(a)(5)alsoauthorizesthereliefrequestedbyappellant.Section128,subdivision(a)(5)provides:8 ` (a)Everycourtshallhavethepowertodoallofthefollowing: ` x` x @T T ........................................................................8 ` (5)Tocontrolinfurtheranceofjustice,theconductofitsministerialofficers,andofallotherpersonsinanymannerconnectedwithajudicialproceedingbeforeit,ineverymatterpertainingthereto. ` x` x  ` Pursuanttosection128,acourthastheauthoritytocompelanattorneytoperformhislegalduty.Forexample,section128authorizesacourttoissueanordercompellingalawyertoserveasadvisorycounseltoaproperdefendant.(_Ligda_Ԁv.SuperiorCourt(1970)5Cal.App.3d811,825826.)No '## reasonappearswhythiscourtshouldnotutilizesection128torequireMr._Darrow_'scompliancewithrule3700(D)(1)oftheRulesofProfessional +'' Conduct. ` Mr._Darrow_Ԁhasamandatorydutytoassistappellatecounselintheproperrepresentationofhisformerclient.ThiscourtshouldorderMr._Darrow_Ԁtocomplywithhismandatoryobligations.@++%CONCLUSION    ` Forthereasonsexpressedabove,thiscourtshouldissueanorderdirectingMr._Darrow_ԀtoprovidethedocumentsspecifiedinappellatecounselsletterofMarch1,2006ortoindicatethathedoesnotpossessthedocuments.Dated:May___,20060 h     Respectfullysubmitted,h h   `     h     ___________________________ `     h     DALLASSACHER `     h     AttorneyforAppellant, `     h     JohnScopes     @ ?  ExhibitA# ?@%# F  %      P@ DECLARATIONOFDALLASSACHER   ` IamanattorneylicensedtopracticeinCalifornia.Ihavebeenappointedbythiscourttorepresentappellantonhispendingappeal. ` Afterreviewingtherecordonappealandcommunicatingwithappellant,ImadeadeterminationthattherewerepossibleissuesofineffectiveassistanceoftrialcounselwhichIwasethicallyboundtoinvestigate.OnJanuary23,2006,Iwrotetotrialcounsel,Clarence_Darrow_,athisofficeaddressasitappearedontheStateBar4w45W565E56ebsite.Inmyletter,IaskedMr._Darrow_ԀtorespondtoaseriesofquestionsregardinghisomissiontorendercertainobjectionsatMr.Scopesstrial. ` AsofFebruary4,2006,IhadnotreceivedaresponsefromMr._Darrow_.Onthatdate,IwrotetoMr._Darrow_ԀandstatedthatIwouldpresumethathehadnotacticaljustificationforanyofhisomissionsunlessIheardfromhimbyFebruary13,2006.Mr._Darrow_ԀdidnotrespondtomyletterofFebruary4,2006. ` OnMarch1,2006,IrealizedthattherewasanadditionalissueofineffectiveassistanceofcounselwhichIwasrequiredtoinvestigate.Onthatdate,IwrotetoMr._Darrow_ԀandaskedhimtoprovidecopiesofdiscoverywhichIpresumedthattheDistrictAttorneyhadgivenhimpriortotrial.IaskedMr._Darrow_Ԁtosendmethediscoveryortoadvisemethatnosuchdiscoveryhadbeenprovided.IalsoaskedMr._Darrow_Ԁtorespondtoa ,(( P      questionregardingtheactionhehadtakenconcerningthecontentsofthediscovery. ` OnMarch10,2006andMarch27,2006,IwrotetoMr._Darrow_ԀandremindedhimthatIwasawaitingaresponsetomyletterofMarch1,2006.AlongwiththeMarch27,2006letter,IenclosedaStateBarethicsopinionwhichprovidesthatitistrialcounselsdutytocooperatewithappellatecounsel.AcopyoftheStateBaropinionisattachedtothisdeclaration.IhavereceivednoresponsetomylettersofMarch10,2006andMarch27,2006. ` Ideclareunderpenaltyofperjurythattheforegoingistrueandcorrect. ` Executedthis___dayofMay2006atSantaClara,California. `     h     _____________________________ `     h     DALLASSACHER   8 XXdXd8  ` @"PROOFOFSERVICE   IdeclarethatIamovertheageof18,notapartytothisactionandmy  businessaddressis100N.WinchesterBlvd.,Suite310,SantaClara,California95050.Onthedateshownbelow,Iservedthewithin MOTION  FORANORDERDIRECTINGATTORNEYCLARENCE_DARROW_ԀTOPROVIDEDOCUMENTSFORAPPELLANTSFILE tothefollowing   partieshereinafternamedby:   X0 ` Placingatruecopythereof,enclosedinasealedenvelopewithpostage    thereonfullyprepaid,intheUnitedStatesmailatSantaClara,California,addressedasfollows: ` `  AttorneyGeneralsOffice0 h 0h h 0      455GoldenGateAvenue0 h 0h h 0  0p  p p  Suite11,0000 0 0h  0h h 0     SanFrancisco,CA941027004[CounselforRespondent]#1#Clarence_Darrow_,Esq./1/065E01.1T2ennessee23aylor3StreetSanJose,CA95112JohnScopes#6# :N-12345-.94440_.  KernValleyStatePrison3000W.CecilAvenueDelano,CA93216# :7#Ideclareunderpenaltyofperjurytheforegoingistrueandcorrect.Executedthis___dayofMay,2006,atSantaClara,California. `     h     ___________________________ `     h     PriscillaA._OHarra_ x  $!! #8#