WPC 79{_Aד|0ò2^:X^Dؙ(Vq4ڡũR^zpב^؈KU3ڱ'|{1<9${9\tYb1.hwBr9H8d\Ja+2=lCǻ~G^fj$n#t\nȟш^$]6-[ 451{T>BIf#0ߏܨT0>Oh 诜?44Dj8w-D=aeb[}0i)iZA?ą h`: (-d#!U N %k 0(qUN^ w@43GV mXNoU>q;Acrobat Distiller,,,,,,0(hH  Z6Times New Roman RegularX($x9 Z6Times New Roman Regular.X/ HE[E  E   HdrT/+003|x U%\  `&Times New Roman  1#Xd# !  _X^XXX8_XX^q@OOINTHECOURTOFAPPEALOFTHESTATEOFCALIFORNIA@++SIXTHAPPELLATEDISTRICTPEOPLEOFTHESTATEOFCALIFORNIA,0 p ]  p p   `     h      p ]NO.H023838 `  PlaintiffandRespondent,0  0p  ] p p   `     h      p ](SANTACLARACO. ` vs.0 0 0h  0h h 0  0p  ]SUPERIORCOURT p p   `     h      p ]NO.208944)MICHAELRAYJOHNSON,     p ]   `     h      p ]0      `  DefendantandAppellant.0  0p  ]#X^X8_f#}p p  __________________________________________]8_XX^ z #8_8_G##X^X8_:#8_XX^@ APPELLANTSPETITIONFORREHEARING ] @ 򀀀 Z 8_8_@44ONAPPEALFROMAJUDGMENTOFTHESUPERIORCOURT T @OFTHESTATEOFCALIFORNIA,COUNTYOFSANTACLARA@W W HONORABLERISEJ.PICHON,JUDGEPRESIDING#8_8_#@ 򀀀 K 8_8_  SIXTHDISTRICTAPPELLATEPROGRAM B" DALLASSACHERAssistantDirectorStateBar#100175100N.WinchesterBlvd.,Suite310SantaClara,CA95050(408)2416171AttorneysforAppellant,MICHAELRAYJOHNSON !-q() q 8^XXdXXd8   O  @OOINTHECOURTOFAPPEALOFTHESTATEOFCALIFORNIA@++SIXTHAPPELLATEDISTRICTPEOPLEOFTHESTATEOFCALIFORNIA,0 p ] p p   `     h      p ]NO.H023838 `  PlaintiffandRespondent,0  0p  ] p p   `     h      p ](SANTACLARACO. ` vs.0 0 0h  0h h 0  0p  ]SUPERIORCOURT p p   `     h      p ]NO.208944)MICHAELRAYJOHNSON,     p ]   `     h      p ]0  }    `  DefendantandAppellant.0  0p  ]#X^X8_#zp p  __________________________________________]8_XX^ w #8_8_0##X^X8_#8_XX^@$INTRODUCTION ]  ` Appellanthascontendedthatthetrialcourterredinholdingthatithadnodiscretiontoimposeconcurrentsentencesinthiscase.(_AOB_Ԁ410.)Thiscourtheldthattheissuewaswaivedsince:(1)therewasnoobjectioninthetrialcourt;and(2)theissuewasnotraisedonappellantspriorappeal.(Opinion,pp.68.)Rehearingisrequiredastobothoftheseconclusions. ` Inhisopeningbrief,appellantofferedtworeasonsastowhythefailuretoobjectinthetrialcourtdidnotbarappellatereviewofhiscontention.(_AOB_Ԁ56.)Thecourtsopinionmakesnomentionofappellantsarguments.Thus,rehearingmustbegranted. '+w&'  ` Inholdingthatappellantscontentionha d  s beenwaivedduetothefailuretoraiseitinapredecessorappeal,thiscourtconcededthatthepointwas notmentionedbytheparties,....(Opinion,p.7.)Asaresult,rehearingismandatedbyGovernmentCodesection68081.I.8 ` REHEARINGISREQUIREDSINCETHISCOURTHAS   FAILEDTOADDRESSAPPELLANTSARGUMENTSREGARDINGTHERULEOFPEOPLEv.SCOTT(1994)9   CAL.4TH331. ` x` x  ` ThiscourtheldthatappellantsclaimofsentencingerrorwaswaivedunderPeoplev.Scott,supra,9Cal.4th331sincehefailedtoobjectinthetrial  court.(Opinion,pp.67.)Insoholding,thecourtfailedtoaddressappellantsargumentstothecontrary.Asfoundinappellantsopeningbrief,theargumentsareasfollows:8 `  Attheoutset,appellantnotesthathedidnotobjecttothetrialcourtsviewthatconsecutivesentencesweremandated.However,thisomissiondoesnotconstituteaforfeitureofhisappellateclaim.Thisissofortworeasons. ` x` x 8 `  First,claimsofsentencingerrorarewaivedbyafailuretoobjectonlywhentheissueconcerns themannerinwhichthetrialcourt_exercise[d_]itssentencingdiscretion....(Peoplev. Y! Scott(1994)9Cal.4th331,356.)Here,thetrialcourtasserted V" thatithadnodiscretiontoexercise.Thus,sinceapureissueoflawisraised,atrialcourtobjectionisnotrequired.(Peoplev. P$  Aguirre(1997)56Cal.App.4th1135,1139;waiverof M% ! sentencingerror onlyoccurswhentheallegederrorinvolvedanexerciseofdiscretion;seealsoInreJustinS.(2001)93 G'"# Cal.App.4th811,814815;probationconditioncouldbechallengedforthefirsttimeonappealsinceitinvolvedapurequestionoflaw.) ` x` x 8 `  Second,an unauthorizedsentencecanbechallenged ;+&' onappealwithoutthebenefitofanobjectioninthetrialcourt.(Scott,supra,9Cal.4thatp.354.)An unauthorizedsentence  includesajudgmentwhichcanbechallengedforthefirsttimeviaahabeaspetition.(Ibid.)Theinstanterrorcanberaisedby  wayofahabeaspetition.(Peoplev._Belmontes_(1983)34  Cal.3d335,348,fn.8; [_w]here_Ԁacourtmayhavebeeninfluencedbyanerroneousunderstandingofthescopeofitssentencingpowers,habeascorpusisaproperremedytosecurereconsiderationofthesentenceimposed.[Citations.])Thus,appellantsclaimisproperlybeforethiscourt.(_AOB_Ԁ56.) ` x` x  ` ItisinterestingtonotethatthequotedargumentswereapparentlypersuasivetothePeoplesincetheymadenowaiverargument.(SeeRB47.)Thus,thiscourtshouldgrantrehearinginordertoaddressappellantsarguments.II.8 ` INSOFARASTHEPARTIESWERENOTGIVENAN w OPPORTUNITYTOBRIEFTHEPOSSIBLEAPPLICATIONOFTHERULEOFPEOPLEV v .SENIOR(1995)33 q CAL.APP.4TH531,REHEARINGISMANDATED. ` x` x  ` Inholdingthatappellantsappellateargumentisbarredbytheruleof h Peoplev.Senior,supra,33Cal.App.4th531,thiscourtconcededthatthepoint b was notmentionedbytheparties,....(Opinion,p.7.)Giventhiscircumstance,rehearingisrequiredpursuanttoGovernmentCodesection68081whichprovides:8 `  BeforetheSupremeCourt,acourtofappeal,ortheappellatedivisionofasuperiorcourtrendersadecisioninaproceedingotherthanasummarydenialofapetitionforanextraordinarywrit,baseduponanissuewhichwasnotproposedorbriefedbyanypartytotheproceeding,thecourtshallaffordthepartiesanopportunitytopresenttheirviewsonthematter ;+&' throughsupplementalbriefing.Ifthecourtfailstoaffordthat  opportunity,arehearingshallbeorderedupontimelypetitionofanyparty.(Emphasisadded.)` x` x  ` Astheemphasizedlanguageindicates,thiscourtismandatedtograntrehearing.Thus,this court must should grantrehearingandprovidethepartieswithanopportunitytobrieftheissue.@00%CONCLUSION    ` Forthereasonsexpressedabove,rehearingviewshouldbegranted.Dated:January__,2003 `     h   Respectfullysubmitted, `     h   DALLASSACHER `     h   AttorneyforAppellant, `     h   MICHAELRAYJOHNSON  k @CERTIFICATEOFCOUNSEL   ` Icertifythatthisbriefcontains1064words. `     h _________________________________ `     h DALLASSACHER `     h AttorneyforAppellant, `     h MICHAELR.JOHNSON      8_8_   ` @"PROOFOFSERVICE   IdeclarethatIamovertheageof18,notapartytothisactionandmy  businessaddressis100N.WinchesterBlvd.,Suite310,SantaClara,California95050.Onthedateshownbelow,IservedthewithinAPPELLANTSPETITIONFORREHEARINGtothefollowingparties   hereinafternamedby:X0 ` Placingatruecopythereof,enclosedinasealedenvelopewithpostage    thereonfullyprepaid,intheUnitedStatesmailatSantaClara,California,addressedasfollows: ` `  AttorneyGeneralsOffice0 h 0h h 0  MichaelR.Johnson    455GoldenGateAvenue0 h 0h h 0  H22086    Suite11,0000 0 0h  0h h 0  CSP_Solano_   SanFrancisco,CA9410270040  0  P.O.Box4000   [AttorneyforRespondent]0 h 0h h 0  Vacaville,CA956964000   #8_ 8_*# 8_8_DistrictAttorneysOffice y 70W.HeddingSt.SanJose,CA95110ClerkoftheSuperiorCourtCriminalDivision190W.HeddingSt.SanJose,CA95110Ideclareunderpenaltyofperjurytheforegoingistrueandcorrect.Executedthis___dayofJanuary,2003,atSantaClara,California. `     h ______________________________ x  L&!"  `     h SueYarbrough p      I'"# #8_ 8_v/#